In the world of identical twins, a peculiar challenge arises for law enforcement. These twins, sharing all of their genes and most of their identifying marks, often find themselves tangled in a web of mistaken identity. Imagine a scenario where one twin commits a crime and cunningly places the blame on the other. The evidence may be overwhelming, and numerous witnesses may attest to their guilt, but the authorities face an extraordinary predicament when it comes to distinguishing between these nearly indistinguishable individuals.
During trials, the judges and jury find themselves perplexed, unable to confidently discern which twin is the true perpetrator. The conventional methods of identification fall short in these extraordinary cases. These identical twins, also known as monozygotic twins, originate from the fertilisation of a single egg that later splits into two. Their genetic makeup is virtually identical, and they share nearly all physical traits, including being of the same sex.
In a world where fingerprints act as unique identifiers, these twins would be an unstoppable force if their prints were different. However, despite their shared genes, their fingerprints exhibit slight variations, providing a glimmer of hope for law enforcement. Thanks to modern technology, the police now rely on fingerprint analysis to differentiate between identical twins, making it the sole means of reining in their criminal activities. Nevertheless, there have been numerous highly debated cases where identical twins managed to evade justice and walk free after committing serious crimes. The inability to definitively assign guilt to a specific twin leaves the courts in a frustrating position. As these cases continue to captivate public attention, society grapples with the challenge of balancing the rights and responsibilities of these strikingly similar individuals who share an uncanny bond.
IN A world where criminal twins seemed to have the upper hand, justice has finally caught up with them. Thanks to the ingenious technique known as “high resolution melt curve analysis” (HRMA), these mischievous twins can no longer outwit forensic investigators. The game of deception just got a lot less identical, and the scales of justice have tilted in favour of truth. Although HRMA is not without its limitations, this breakthrough paves the way for a practical and accessible test that will revolutionize forensic casework involving twins. With this hurdle overcome, DNA profiling solidifies its place as an indispensable tool, fortifying the accuracy and reliability of criminal justice systems around the globe. The days of twin trickery are numbered, and the world is a safer place for it.
Satish & Sabarish
Malaysia, 2003:
Identical twins, Satish-Sabarish, arrested for drug trafficking. Both faced the death penalty. Police couldn’t identify the true culprit. Both acquitted. Media reports confirm the twin brothers escaped execution as the court couldn’t prove who committed the crime. The judge cited their indistinguishable features, calling it a “unique case.”
Hassan & Abbas
Germany, 2009
Identical twins Hassan and Abbas were arrested in Germany in 2009 for a multi-million dollar jewelry heist. Despite abundant evidence, the police couldn’t determine the real culprit between the brothers. Eventually, both twins were acquitted due to the difficulty in distinguishing them during the trial.
Charles & George
US, 1952
During WWII, Charles and George Finn served in the US Army Air Corps. George instructed while Charles piloted B-17s. In 1952, they bought a C-46 plane from a district school for their airline. When the government halted the purchase, one brother hid it in the Nevada desert. The FBI found it, but no one could identify who out of twins hid it, so they weren’t prosecuted.
Albert Ebenezer Fox & Ebenezer Albert Fox
England, 1857
Known as the Twin Foxes, exploited their resemblance to challenge English authorities and seek recompense for wrongful convictions. They amassed a staggering 150 poaching convictions. Their case shed light on the unique nature of fingerprints, proving their value in identifying individuals as distinguished twins.
Orlando & Brandon Nembhard
USA, 2011
In a nightclub altercation, Sir Xavier Brooks was fatally shot. Based on visual testimony, Orlando Nembhard was arrested for the murder, but complications arose as police discovered his identical twin, Brandon. As the murder weapon was missing, there was no conclusion regarding fingerprints and DNA, thus visual identification by witnesses proved unreliable. The case remains inconclusive, leaving the shooter unknown.
Patric & James
England, 2016
Patrick Hennessy, of Cheltenham was arrested for possessing illegal weapon and driving dangerously but he blamed his identical twins James for the same. DNA tests failed to determine which brother was responsible, leading to their acquittal. Prosecutors couldn’t provide evidence to disprove the claim that one brother’s twin was the real offender, resulting in not guilty verdicts for both.
Jerome & Tyrone Cooper
Michigan, 1999
Identical twin brothers were suspect of a sexual assault case in Grand Rapids, Michigan. The victim’s DNA matched Jerome’s, who was already in prison, but authorities discovered Tyrone’s existence. The challenge was in determining guilt as they are identical twins with matching DNA.