The sincerity of the proposed diesel vehicle tax increase in promoting environmental sustainability remains unclear. It leaves us pondering whether it represents a significant step towards progress or merely gives an illusion of advancement.
In recent years, diesel vehicles have come under increased scrutiny and faced growing pressure from governments and environmental advocates around the world. In India, this pressure has manifested in discussions about higher taxes on diesel vehicles, with Road Transport Minister Nitin Gadkari recently stirring the pot by suggesting the possibility of imposing an additional 10% GST as a “pollution tax” on such vehicles.
However, Gadkari later backtracked that there is currently no active proposal for such a tax hike under consideration by the government. He emphasised the government’s dedication to combating air pollution caused by harmful fuels like diesel and promoting cleaner alternatives. Despite this clarification, his initial statement had a significant impact on the stock market, particularly affecting the automotive sector. This reaction was driven by the perception that Minister’s comments were consistent with wider policy discussions about diesel vehicles in India.
Gadkari’s remarks have reignited debates about the possible hike in rates and its implications for the future of diesel cars in India. Given the existing tax rate of 28% on diesel cars, coupled with an extra cess based on engine capacity, leading to a total tax burden of nearly 50% on these vehicles, it hasn’t been beneficial over the years. This substantial tax structure has led to questions about the rationale behind a fresh initiative to raise the taxation when it hasn’t been successful in reducing vehicle sales.
Interestingly, just over three months, a committee appointed by the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas proposed phasing out diesel four-wheelers by 2027 in cities with populations exceeding 1 million. This proposal is part of a larger initiative aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions and promoting the transition to electric and gas-powered vehicles.
The Global Pushback Against Diesel Vehicles
The global resistance against diesel vehicles is not limited to India. Countries around the globe are taking steps to cut down on diesel use due to its significant contribution to air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. For instance, the European Parliament has passed a law to prohibit the sale of petrol and diesel cars from 2035 onwards. Similarly, the United Kingdom is planning to ban the sale of new petrol and diesel cars by 2030. These actions reflect a growing consensus that diesel is not a sustainable option for the future.
In India, diesel makes up about 40% of petroleum product consumption. Despite the advantages of diesel engines, such as higher fuel economy and torque, they emit higher levels of pollutants, including nitrogen oxides (NOx). The negative image of diesel was further amplified by the Volkswagen scandal in 2015, which exposed cheating on emissions tests.
Moreover, the transition to Bharat Stage VI (BS-VI) emission norms in India presented a significant challenge for car manufacturers. The high costs associated with upgrading diesel engines to meet these standards led many automakers, including Maruti Suzuki, Tata Motors, Mahindra, and Honda, to withdraw from the diesel segment. As a result, the contribution of passenger vehicles to overall diesel demand has significantly decreased.
The Indian automotive market is currently witnessing a significant shift in consumer preferences regarding diesel vehicles. According to recent data, diesel cars have seen a substantial decline in their market share, accounting for less than 20% of total passenger vehicle sales during the fiscal year 2021-22. This trend has continued into 2023, with the share of diesel vehicles in the passenger vehicle segment dropping to approximately 18% from January to July. This is a significant decrease from their peak at 47.9% in 2014.
Interestingly, the luxury car segment tells a different story. Diesel variants have seen a slight increase in their market share, rising from 31% in 2021 to 33% in the current year.
In terms of automakers, Mahindra and Mahindra lead the pack with the highest market share for diesel cars. They have secured a substantial 47% of unit sales so far in 2023, marking a significant increase from their 28% market share in 2021. Hyundai and Kia follow closely behind.
These evolving dynamics in the Indian automotive market highlight changing consumer preferences and industry trends, particularly regarding diesel vehicles. It’s crucial to keep an eye on these shifts as they have implications for both manufacturers and policymakers.
Diesel Vs. EV, A Cleaner Alternative
The broader context of emissions is vital when assessing the future of diesel vehicles. Electric vehicles (EVs) have surfaced as a cleaner substitute to both petrol and diesel cars. Despite debates about the environmental impact of EVs based on their charging methods, they generally emit less carbon, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen dioxide than vehicles with internal combustion engines.
Efforts are underway globally to reduce emissions from the transportation sector. India, aligning with these global efforts, has set ambitious goals to electrify a significant portion of its vehicle fleet by 2030.
The discussions about diesel vehicles in India and worldwide underscore the necessity for a balanced strategy that addresses environmental issues while considering the economic implications for consumers and manufacturers. The transition to cleaner fuels and technologies needs careful management to ensure a sustainable future.
The potential additional tax on diesel vehicles may not be immediate but it signifies the government’s dedication to emission reduction and cleaner alternatives promotion. As technology progresses and EV infrastructure enhances, consumers can anticipate more options that are eco-friendly and cost-effective.
The global move away from diesel vehicles indicates an increasing consciousness about pollution reduction and climate change combat. India, being one of the largest automotive markets globally, is actively involved in this transition. As technology progresses and emission standards tighten, both the automotive industry and consumers need to adapt to a landscape focused on sustainability and cleaner transportation solutions.
The Minister’s proposal aligns with broader policy discussions aimed at reducing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions. The future of diesel vehicles in India may be at a turning point, and all stakeholders should keep a close eye on this evolving narrative. Whether this proposal represents a genuine policy shift or merely a diversion is yet to be seen, but it certainly highlights the urgency to address environmental issues in India’s transportation sector.
We strive to make a lasting impact on India’s policy and planning landscape through fair, unbiased, and incisive research based journalism.
But we can’t do it alone.
Together, we can create a better India, where policies are fair, planning is unbiased, and the truth prevails. Your contribution matters, and we shall be immensely grateful for your support.